10.  Cf. V. Brants, Xenophon Economiste, reprint from Revue Catholique de Louvain, 1881, pp. 4 ff.

11.  Ely, Studies in Historical and Political Science, 2d series, pp. 48 ff., especially p. 64, where he states that it is a return to the Greek view.

12.  Ely, Outlines of Economics, 1908, pp. 4 ff.; cf. Seligman, Principles of Economy, (1905), pp. 4 ff., especially p. 14, where he even quotes the sentences of Ruskin with approval: “There is no wealth but life”; “Nor can anything be wealth except to a noble person” (Unto This Last, IV, 77 [Vol. XVII, 105]). All citations will be from the Allen library edition unless otherwise stated.

13.  Schoenberg, Handbuch der polit. Econ. (1890), I, 56.