Codal
nydus/The Game of LogicPublic
Página 56 de 92
Table of Contents

Respuestas torcidas

  7.  | 1 | 1 |  It might be thought that the proper
      |   |   |
       -------     -------
                  |   |   |
Diagram would be  |   1 1 |, in order to express "some
                  |   |   |
                   -------
x exist": but this is really contained in "some x are y'."
To put a red counter on the division-line would only tell
us "ONE OF THE compartments is occupied", which we
know already, in knowing that ONE is occupied.
                          -------
                         |   |   |
  8.  No x are y.  i.e.  | 0 |   |
                         |   |   |
                          -------
                             -------
                            |   |   |
  9.  Some x are y'.  i.e.  |   | 1 |
                            |   |   |
                             -------
                           -------
                          |   |   |
 10.  All x are y.  i.e.  | 1 | 0 |
                          |   |   |
                           -------
                            -------
                           |   |   |
 11.  Some x are y.  i.e.  | 1 |   |
                           |   |   |
                            -------
                          -------
                         |   |   |
 12.  No x are y.  i.e.  | 0 |   |
                         |   |   |
                          -------
                                             -------
                                            |   |   |
 13.  Some x are y, and some are y'.  i.e.  | 1 | 1 |
                                            |   |   |
                                             -------
56