Had the double decomposition been complete in the case where one equivalent of nitric acid was taken per equivalent of Na2SO4 then according to calculation from similar data there should have been absorbed -2,989 units of heat, while in reality only -1,752 units were absorbed. Hence Thomsen concluded that a displacement of only about two-thirds of the sulphuric acid had taken place—that is, the ratio k : k′ for the reaction ½Na2SO4 + HNO3 and NaNO3 + ½H2SO4 is equal, as for ethereal salts, to 4. By taking this figure and admitting the above supposition, Thomsen found that for all mixtures of soda with nitric acid, and of sodium nitrate with sulphuric acid, the amounts of heat followed Guldberg and Waage's law; that is, the limit of decomposition reached was greater the greater the mass of acid added. The relation of hydrochloric to sulphuric acid gave the same results. Therefore the researches of Thomsen fully confirm the hypotheses of Guldberg and Waage and the doctrine of Berthollet.
Thomsen concludes his investigation with the words: (a) ‘When equivalent quantities of NaHO, HNO3 (or HCl) and ½H2SO4 react on one another in an aqueous solution, then two-thirds of the soda combines with the nitric and one-third with the sulphuric acid; (b) this subdivision repeats itself, whether the soda be taken combined with nitric or with sulphuric acid; (c) and therefore nitric acid has double the tendency to combine with the base that sulphuric acid has, and hence in an aqueous solution it is a stronger acid than the latter.’ ‘It is therefore necessary,’ Thomsen afterwards remarks, ‘to have an expression indicating the tendency of an acid for the saturation of bases. This idea cannot be expressed by the word affinity, because by this term is most often understood that force which it is necessary to overcome in order to decompose a substance into its component parts. This force should therefore be measured by the amount of work or heat employed for the decomposition of the substance. The above-mentioned phenomenon is of an entirely different nature,’ and Thomsen introduces the term avidity, by which he designates the tendency of acids for neutralisation. ‘Therefore the avidity of nitric acid with respect to soda is twice as great as the avidity of sulphuric acid.
An exactly similar result is obtained with hydrochloric acid, so that its avidity with respect to soda is also double the avidity of sulphuric acid. Experiments conducted with other acids showed that not one of the acids investigated had so great an avidity as nitric acid; some had a greater avidity than sulphuric acid, others less, and in some instances the avidity = 0.’ The reader will naturally see clearly that the path chosen by Thomsen deserves to be worked out, for his results concern important questions of chemistry, but great faith cannot be placed in the deductions he has already arrived at, because great complexity of relations is to be seen in the very method of his investigation. It is especially important to turn attention to the fact that all the reactions investigated are reactions of double decomposition. In them A and B do not combine with C and distribute themselves according to their affinity or avidity for combination, but reversible reactions are induced. MX and NY give MY and NX, and conversely; therefore the affinity or avidity for combination is not here directly determined, but only the difference or relation of the affinities or avidities. The affinity of nitric acid not only for the water of constitution, but also for that serving for solution, is much less than that of sulphuric acid. This is seen from thermal data.